A sample text widget

Etiam pulvinar consectetur dolor sed malesuada. Ut convallis euismod dolor nec pretium. Nunc ut tristique massa.

Nam sodales mi vitae dolor ullamcorper et vulputate enim accumsan. Morbi orci magna, tincidunt vitae molestie nec, molestie at mi. Nulla nulla lorem, suscipit in posuere in, interdum non magna.

China oversteps it on Rio & Kadeer

There are now absurd claims by China that bribery by Rio Tinto has cost it $123b over 6 years – more than the total value of iron ore exports by Rio to China.  The absurdity of these claims is compounded by the anger of the Chinese given that the current contract price offered to China by Rio is 20% below the current price of iron ore in spot markets. Cool down fellas you have got this seriously wrong.

Note how China Daily reported the claims. Here it is agreed that no evidence has been produced to support the preposterous Chinese assertions – how could it?. Ominously however this official newspaper account extols the need to protect state secrets in the commercial area.   

This is ominous news for those seeking to further their commercial relationship with China.  While China has asserted the need for ‘non-interference in its internal affairs’ with respect to its legal system this will not be accepted by any fair-minded individual. Mr. Stern Hu has been arrested without charges being laid and without the opportunity to seek legal representation. Moreover, the Chinese media and the Chinese Foreign Ministry have asserted his guilt prior to any trial being held. Is this a legal system that deserves respect?

Given its size China can be a force for good or evil in the world. The developed world derives many benefits from China achieving its development goals but when China acts as an intolerant, bellicose child who has suddenly come into newfound wealth it does not send out good signals.  Moreover, these actions harm both China and China’s suppliers such as Australia.

It has been a bad week for China in Australia with Chinese diplomats and angry Chinese demonstrators attempting to suppress the participation of Uighur leader Ms. Rebiya Kadeer in a Melbourne film festival as well as objecting to a screening of a film on her life.  Australians naturally resent the attempts by an authoritarian regime to censor views in Australia. That is not saying that Ms. Kadeer has a monopoly on the truth but she has the right to exposit her views.  Particularly when those opposing her are engaging in the types of shenanagins we see with Mr Hu.

6 comments to China oversteps it on Rio & Kadeer

  • derrida derider

    Yeah, they’re looking for foreigners to blame for their own stuffing of the negotiations. Not that there’s anything uniquely Chinese or authoritarian about that – the most impeccably democratic politicians (and electorates) will always grab at a chance to blame foreigners for their own bungling. Patriotism is the last refuge etc. The sole difference is that in democracies said politicians can’t tell the courts what to do.

    Which thought doesn’t help Stephen Hu much. But as I said elsewhere, the last thing we should do is urge the Chinese to charge him – once he’s charged considerations of face will make sure he’s convicted and given a lengthy sentence. Much better to speak quietly and try to do a deal behind closed doors.

  • […] the whole story here: hc aggregated by […]

  • hc

    DD, I think the Chinese have gone so far out on a limb on this one that his future is grim. I hope I am wrong.

    A deal will probably be done down the line – it is sad.

    Apart from Hu the economic relation between Australia and China will be damaged for quite a while by this action. We all lose – Hu most of all.

  • Uncle Milton

    I must say that I was pleasantly surprised by Robert Doyle’s refusal to cave in to Chinese demands to not screen that film at the Melbourne Town Hall. Doyle has more character and backbone than I thought.

  • […] here: Harry Clarke » China oversteps it: upon Rio & Kadeer This entry was posted on 星期天, 八月 9th, 2009 at 9:17 下午 and is filed under […]

  • conrad

    Perhaps they should start selling into the spot market far more as a protest. I imagine that would make supply a nightmare, especially if BHP did it too.

Leave a Reply